General Walkthrough

• Choose “You should investigate the area more”.
• It doesn't matter if you trust Flowey or not.
• Follow Meiko’s instructions; ACT: Check -> ACT: Talk.
• ACT: Check Froggit -> ACT: Compliment -> MERCY: Spare
• If you want, wait for Meiko, nothing happens and you leave the room anyway.
• Talk to the Froggit after the SAVE Point dialogue, they will give you 3 golden coins.
• Go to the left and get the Creature Candy!
• Choose your preference! (It doesn’t matter)
• Napstarui: Cheer them until the fight is over so you can get the 4 golden coins.
• Go to the Spider Bake Sale, and buy the Ribbon Donut.
• After sleeping, pick up the Pie. Don’t eat it.
• In Meiko's fight, spare her until she stops attacking.
• Your progress is saved. You should have everything by this point (the stick, the creature candy, the ribbon donut and the butterscotch pie)

For the Violent Neutral, you need to be aggressive at every opportunity you are given. Threaten, be rude and, most importantly, you have to have the wooden stick (Choose “You should investigate the area more”).